Search Salon

- - - - - - - - - - - -

Recently in Salon Books

Dear Mr. Blue
Faithful for now
Does my crush on another woman mean there's something wrong with my marriage?
By Garrison Keillor
[02/08/00]

Reviews
"S.: A Novel About the Balkans" by Slavenka Drakulic
A fierce novel brings home the horrors of the Bosnian war -- rape, torture and the sexual slavery of Muslim women.
By Brigitte Frase
[02/08/00]

Reviews
"Two Moons" by Thomas Mallon
A beautiful but heavy-handed new novel by the author of "Henry and Clara" evokes a post-Civil War Washington of scheming politicians and love-struck astronomers.
By Christopher Shea
[02/07/00]

Ivory Tower
The tedious life of a T.A. serf
I wanted to learn to teach, but found myself buying Chanukah presents for a tenured dinosaur's niece.
By James Nestor
[02/07/00]

Book Bag
New bohemian classics
The author of "Weird Like Us: My Bohemian America" picks five must-reads for a new generation.
By Ann Powers
[02/07/00]

Complete archives for Books

- - - - - - - - - - - -

- - - - - - - - - - - -

"I'm really shocked by the University of Arizona Press," says Allen Barra, a journalist and the author of the recent book "Inventing Wyatt Earp: His Life and Many Legends" (Caroll & Graf, 1998). "Fraud has been committed here, but that is no longer the story. The story is that the University of Arizona Press is perpetuating this fraud, and they've known about it from the beginning."

I Married Wyatt Earp: The Recollections of Josephine Sarah Marcus Earp Edited by Glenn G. Boyer University of Arizona Press, 277 pages Buy this book at B&N.com

According to Barra, the controversy began in the early 1990s, when historians began to doubt the existence of a collection of Josephine's personal memoirs, known as the Clum manuscript, that Glenn Boyer claims he used to create the vital Tombstone section of "I Married Wyatt Earp." But the rumbling escalated into a full-fledged scandal in October 1999. That's when newly appointed University of Arizona Press director Christine Szuter wrote to Barra, who had been prodding the press for years to investigate Boyer's sources, and acknowledged that there was a problem with the book.

To remedy the problem, Szuter wrote, the press intended to "redesign the cover and rewrite the cover copy, change the authorship from Josephine Earp to Glenn Boyer, and add a publisher's note regarding sources used in the book." A puzzling response, says Barra, who was furious that a scholarly press, or any press for that matter, could be so cavalier with such fundamental issues as authorship and the authenticity of sources. Change it to "I Married Wyatt Earp" by Glenn Boyer? "Is that not tantamount to an admission of fraud?" asks Barra. "How can you say for 23 years that a book is a memoir, let it be used as a primary source for historians, and then say all of a sudden that it is fictional and that everyone should have known it was fictional all along? Can anyone offer any parallel for this?"

Even more troubling than Szuter's proposed solution is the fact that in the past month the University of Arizona has instituted a media blackout on the subject of Boyer and has referred all questions about "I Married Wyatt Earp" to university lawyers. University of Arizona attorney Mike Proctor confirmed that "a full review" of the "publication issues" surrounding the book was under way, but that no one at the press or the university would speak on the matter. "That is solely because of inaccurate media coverage, no other reason," noted an obviously peeved Proctor. "I have been very open up to the point where we got burned and now we just can't go there."

Proctor would not say on the record who in the media had "burned" the university or what "publication issues" his office is delving into. But he did angrily single out one publication for misreporting information: the Daily Wildcat, the student newspaper of the University of Arizona. Contrary to what that paper reported, says Proctor, his office would not be reviewing Boyer's questionable sources. "I am not qualified to look at sources, I am a lawyer." So what is Proctor looking at if not claims that the author fudged his sources? "I am just looking at our entire file on the book, start to finish, trying to identify objectively publication issues, and then work toward the best resolution of those issues." Would charges of academic fraud and creating fictional source material be considered publication issues? Proctor would not say. "Sorry, but you're all getting the same thing. No comment."

"A public university refusing to talk to the press? Richard Nixon would be proud," says Casey Tefertiller a Bay Area journalist and the author of "Wyatt Earp: The Man Behind the Legend" (John Wiley and Sons, 1997). Like Barra, Tefertiller has been a vocal critic of the university and Boyer. "If you feel you have been misrepresented in the press, you don't institute a blackout, you insist on a correction. For a journalist, all a blackout does is hint that there is a story there after all."

According to Los Angeles New Times reporter Tony Ortega, who was a reporter in Phoenix in 1998, there definitely is a story. Ortega is the man credited by many with blowing the cover off "I Married Wyatt Earp" in a 1998 series of articles in the Phoenix New Times by doing what many critics of Boyer had not the time or the stomach to do. Tipped off by Barra to the increasingly bizarre controversy brewing in his backyard, Ortega visited Boyer in the summer of 1998 at his sprawling Arizona ranch. There he learned that Boyer could not, indeed, produce the source material he claimed to possess, specifically, the disputed Clum manuscript.

Next page | The author calls his critics rapists and pedophiles